So I have been doing some church shopping of late, and the last couple of weeks have found me at a local church that seems to have a good bit of potential…
Potential… that word has haunted me on and off for many years. A big part of who I am and how I am wired is making things better than they currently are. This morning, as I sat in the worship service, I could not help but think about how the service could be tweaked to make it better. Contrary to the beliefs of some, this is not done out of a critical spirit, this is done because it is who I am… and in the deep down, core of my being, I desire nothing more than to see the church excel in what it does, and to see the kingdom expand through the impact of the local church.
Last week I went away from the service feel that something was just not there… This week, I was feeling the same thing but unsure of what it was until right before the sermon when the pastor used a video clip. As I sat there watching the clip, the thought flashed through my mind “this just does not fit this service”.
Thinking back, it began to make sense… the feeling that I felt the week before, and today stemmed from the sense that the service just was. There wasn’t a sense that the service was crafted, there wasn’t a sense that it was a living, breathing organism… it just was.
Now I know that there are those out there that will interpret what I am saying and call me some kind of heathen, and tell me that I am watering down the gospel, or trying to put on a show, or some crap like that, but fortunately my blog really isnt popular, and I doubt that they will be reading this… but I believe that there is a huge importance in the way that a worship service is crafted… and how it is viewed by those that are leading.
From my experience, there seems to be two ways to look at a worship service. The first view is that it is a static presentation, an hour to two hours in which everything is programed to the minute, and things happen on schedule. Not having a theater background, this is how I would envision a broadway show being done. There are rehersals, and things are repeated enough that there is minimal chance of a mistake. While this can provide a certain degree of excellence, I fully believe that this view of a service can suck the life out of a body in a very subtle, but dangerous way. The second view is that a worship service is a living, breathing organism. It is a dynamic period of time that is handled loosely and allowed to be fluid. While there is rehersal and preparation, it is done in a way to build familiarity but at the same time there is an openness to what may happen.
So, the last paragraph sounded kind of nebulous… basically what I am getting at is the need for an openness to the move of the spirit, rather than a need to get everything done.
I am convinced that the ability to do this rests firmly on the shoulders of the worship leader.
Worship Leaders are a rare breed. There are plenty of excellent musicians that can direct worship, but to really lead a worship service, to really shepherd a body of believers through a worship service takes a special gifting. I have met a few people with this gift along the way… and have been blessed to be in a service where they have been leading…
As I look back at the church that I visited today, I see so much potential… I see a very talented band, and a senior pastor who is a good communicator. I see a desire to use creativity in the service, and a desire to use different mediums to convey the message.
I also see the need for a worship leader. While there are a couple of people up front leading songs, there is no one that is shepherding the service… a need for someone to come alongside and help craft the service working through the ebb and the flow of the service, develop a unifying theme for the service and put together elements that fit together…
I used to think that there was something wrong with me for always looking at how to improve church. I used to think that I had a critical sprirt, or just couldn’t see the positive in anything. What I am realizing is that this is not the case… this is how I am wired… this is what I am wired for… I see the good in churches, I also see ways to make them better, and stronger… A while ago someone recomended that I go into consulting… While that may be a possibility in the future, for now I love the church far too much to not be involved in it on a local level…
***edit*** After soaking on this for a couple hours, I feel like I need to clarify one thing. I do not look for perfection in the church… I always expect for there to be a need for further improvement, and this is not a place where I need to just suck it up and be happy where I am at… I am. Thus far, I have enjoyed my experience at this church, at the same time I am trying to process how I process stuff…

You have some good insights.
But is my task to evaluate and improve others, or to be evaluated and learn from the Presence of God no matter what others do? As the song says, “I’m coming back to the heart of worship/and it’s all about You …” “I’ll give you more than a song, for a song in itself/is not what you have required.”
Best wishes to you!
Yeah, I always flip flop back and forth between thinking that I’m too critical and negative, and thinking that I am thinking about constructive criticism. Usually, I come to the conclusion that I’m just being negative… but that’s just me.
It’s really hard for some people to get the idea of having a looser structure that leaves room for things to just happen… It sounds too charismatic for some people, which I guess I understand. But, I think that it might be something good that we can learn from Charismatics even if we don’t necessarily agree with everything that they might do.
But yeah, it definitely requires someone who can lead that type of thing well, otherwise it could just be a disaster.
I know this is an old post but I just read it. I think it’s interesting that you point out the difference between good musicians and good worship leaders. I’ve noticed the same thing. Granted I have a hard time explaining it but I can tell the difference. Thanks for your insight on it.
-a